Pugh Matrix

An Overview of the Pugh Matrix: What Is It and How Does It Work?


Summary: Pugh Matrix

The Pugh Matrix, or the Decision Matrix or Selection Matrix, is a criteria-based matrix used to compare and evaluate multiple design options against a set of criteria. Stuart Pugh first developed it in the 1960s while working at Unilever Research Laboratory. The matrix allows teams to quickly and easily compare alternative improvement opportunities against each other to identify the design solutions that best meet the customers needs.

Are you a project manager or change agent trying to identify the right solution for your organisation? Then you’re in luck. The Pugh method has been around for decades. It is one of the most effective decision-making tools out there when it comes to understanding what features make up an ideal product or service versus a non-ideal alternative. With this tool, it becomes more accessible than ever before to take complex problems and break them down into manageable chunks that can be analysed with precision – so you can focus on find the best final solution that meets your customers needs. In this article we will take a look at how by using an evaluation criteria approach, we can build optimal hybrid solution options to find the right improvement opportunity.

What is the Pugh Matrix, and why is it essential for solution selection


The Pugh Matrix (often called a criteria rating form) is a tool that uses a criteria based matrix to identify the best solution after identify relevant user requirement criteria. It involves comparing each solution against a standard set of specified evaluation criteria to find the best possible solution against viable alternatives.

What makes a Pugh method different from others is that it doesn’t just look for the most popular or highest-rated solution against the various weighting strategies, but it identifies those improvement concepts that score well across all the various criteria. This makes it influential in decision-making as it helps to identify a variety of possible solutions, even if they don’t necessarily have the highest scores – allowing individuals and organisations to make more informed decisions about their selections. The criteria based decision matrix, helps do a final in depth analysis that moves away from very generic criteria an optimal scoring mechanism that helps identify the best solution from several viable alternatives.

The Pugh Matrix was originally invented by Dr Stuart Pugh as a solution matrix that is an effective decision-making tool that takes into account all criteria when selecting solutions – not just those with high scores or ratings. This makes it invaluable for project managers and change agents who need to identify intricate solutions to difficult challenges quickly and accurately.

With the help of the Pugh tool, you can easily break down complex problems into manageable chunks that can be analysed with precision – giving you more control over your organisation’s success in today’s rapidly changing world!

Step-by-Step Guide to Constructing a Pugh Matrix


Knowing how to construct a this decision grid is essential for proper decision-making, especially when comparing the alternatives you need to consider. The pugh matrices is simple comparison method and can be efficiently utilised if you follow a few basic steps.

Step 1: Develop a Comprehensive List of Criteria

Before you begin constructing the Pugh Matrix, it is important to develop and list out the evaluation crtieria that will be used to evaluate each solution. This should include functional criteria (such as cost, complexity, quality, etc.) and non-functional criteria (such as scalability, maintainability, usability, etc.) as well as various customer experience requirements if needed. At this time, you will also want to consider the relative importance of each criteria. By weighting each solution through a team based process, you can find which criteria are of more of less importance and avoid having too many criteria.

Pugh Matrix - Step 1

Step 2: Identify and List Alternative Solutions

Once you have developed a comprehensive list of the evaluation criteria, the next step is to identify potential solutions that could meet those criteria. Make sure to include all feasible alternatives (including existing products/services or custom-built ones) in order for the Pugh Matrix to be effective. 

Pugh Matrix - Step 2

Step 3: Rank Each Solution on each Criterion

Once you have identified a list of solutions, the next step is to identify a standard solution and rank each solution on each criterion against the standard solution assigning it a score ranging from -1 (appears worse), 0 (equal importance), or +1 (appears superior) than the standard solution. This is a very simple criteria scoring approach, but this weighting system helps to This will allow you to compare and contrast the different alternatives to identify the best one for your needs.

Pugh Matrix - Step 3

Step 4: Calculate the Total Score for Each Option

After ranking each option on every criterion, you can then do the weighted scoring for that particular solution and record it as its total score. This total score can then compare all solutions and decide which is most suitable for your organisation. 


Pugh Matrix - Step 4

Step 5: Select the Preferred Solution

After comparing all the solutions and their respective total scores, select the one with the highest score as your preferred solution. This should be your final decision regarding which option to implement in order to achieve success. However, it is worth considering all the various alternatives at this stage as the pugh analysis can help combine potential solutions.

Pugh Matrix - Step 5


How to Interpret Results from a Pugh Matrix


Understanding the results of a Pugh Matrix and the decision matrix can be incredibly useful when deciding between different solutions. You can use the pugh matrix to help to identify which option offers the best value by taking into account multiple criteria and weighting them to reach an overall score. Focusing on pugh matrix weighting and assigning values to each variation makes it easier to determine which solution meets your needs most effectively. It then becomes far simpler to choose the right option with confidence, knowing that you have considered all aspects thoroughly through unbiased analysis.

Benefits of using a Pugh Matrix in your decision-making process


The Pugh is a powerful tool for identifying the optimal solution from multiple alternatives. It provides organisations with an easy and efficient way to evaluate each option and its potential effects by systematic comparison. Benefits of this process include improved decision-making ability, prioritisation of possibilities according to which best fits their individual needs, and clarity on trade-offs between criteria. A well-executed Pugh Matrix assessment should consider both qualitative and quantitative factors, leading to shortlists that identify the most beneficial solution amongst a range of possibilities. With the right approach and implementation, such a matrix can be used to make informed decisions that result in effective outcomes that bring higher returns on investment.

Common Challenges and Mistakes to Avoid When Using the Pugh Matrix


In today’s digital world, organisations must make countless decisions. One way decision-makers can choose the best option is by using the Pugh Matrix. But this concept also has its challenges and mistakes that should be avoided. Common challenges surrounding the Pugh Matrix include assessing multiple criteria and understanding how to weigh different options across these criteria. Additionally, organisations should thoroughly research each solution before assigning weights and avoid taking a “gut-feel” approach when selecting an optimal solution. An unbalanced analysis of solutions can lead to wrong decisions—and no one wants that. To ensure success when using the Pugh Matrix, go into it with clear goals and objectives, research all solutions comprehensively, establish standardised criteria, focus on total cost consideration, collaborate with various stakeholders, and above all else rely on data to inform your decisions rather than instinct.

Creative Ways to Make Use of the Pugh Matrix for Complex Solutions


When looking for the best solutions to complex problems, it can be difficult to decipher what is truly the most optimal approach. The Pugh Matrix is an excellent tool used by professionals across various industries that can help make sense of complicated situations and allow you to identify the right solution. There are creative ways of utilising the Pugh Matrix that can go beyond traditional methods, allowing you to assess options effectively and accurately while saving valuable time.



The Pugh Matrix is an invaluable tool for making decisions when faced with multiple options. It allows organisations to evaluate each option and its potential impacts by comparing them side-by-side, taking into account both qualitative and quantitative factors. With the right approach and implementation, the pugh matrix can be used to make informed decisions that result in positive outcomes with higher returns on investment. However, it is important to ensure that the pugh matrix is applied correctly, which requires avoiding common pitfalls such as unbalanced analysis or gut-feel decision making.

Our Newsletter

Reagan Pannell

Reagan Pannell

Reagan Pannell is a highly accomplished professional with 15 years of experience in building lean management programs for corporate companies. With his expertise in strategy execution, he has established himself as a trusted advisor for numerous organisations seeking to improve their operational efficiency.

Jump To Section

Yellow Belt Course

Green Belt Course

LEAN SIX SIGMA Online Courses

A Lean Six Sigma Green Belt Masterclass

only €999

Ready to start your journey into the world of Lean with this free course?


A Lean focused continious improvement certification course

only £119

Propel your career forward, tackle complex problems and drive change

Only £167

The ultimate fast-track for future leadership

only £849

Become an expert in change management and complex problem-solving.

Only £1649

Lean Accelerator Program

discover the power of problem-solving


download the syllabus